Recent Newmarket Decisions Found on CanLII - October 2026
Case summaries are CanLII AI-Generated
Civil
Ferrari Estate v. Sukhram, 2026 ONCA 745 - On appeal from the order of Justice Sunil S. Mathai of the Superior Court of Justice, dated October 28, 2025, with reasons reported at 2025 ONSC 6062.
Real property — Sale of lands — Agreements of purchase and sale — Registrar’s dismissal — Appeals
Talpade v. AMJ Campbell Company Toronto East, 2026 ONCA 712
On a motion for security for costs in an appeal from an order striking a claim, the judge ordered security because the appeal appeared frivolous and vexatious, the appellants had unpaid cost orders and insufficient means, and the notice of appeal lacked particulars. Security of $14,900 was ordered, with $5,600 costs.
Orsetto v. 2416022 Ontario Ltd. et al., 2026 ONSC 5689 - Justice Mathai
On a motion to be added as a party after default judgment in an oppression proceeding, the judge finds the moving party’s claimed beneficial interest in a shareholder’s shares may be affected by the ordered sale. However, delay and prejudice to existing parties justify refusing joinder. Limited standing is granted to make submissions on the sale’s manner.
Lincoln Gate Homes Inc. v. DeFrancesco, 2026 ONSC 5606 - Justice De Sa
On a motion to strike a claim and discharge a Mareva injunction, the Court holds there was a strong prima facie case and no material non-disclosure warranting discharge. It grants leave to amend the pleading to remove the corporation as a plaintiff, allowing the action to proceed with the individual plaintiff, and directs further submissions on varying the Mareva amount and access for legal fees.
Criminal
R. v. Cheng, 2026 ONCJ 636 - Justice Perlin
In a sentencing proceeding following guilty pleas, the court denies a conditional discharge. It finds that a police employee’s unauthorised police-database searches and misleading use of a police-style badge involved breach of trust and required denunciation and general deterrence. It imposes a suspended sentence with 12 months’ probation and related conditions.
R. v. Romano, 2026 ONSC 5865 - Justice Di Luca
In criminal sentencing for failing to stop after an accident causing death, the judge finds significant, prolonged recklessness and major victim impact. Despite remorse, no record, and strong rehabilitative prospects, a conditional sentence is rejected as insufficiently denunciatory. The offender is sentenced to 12 months’ custody and a 24‑month driving prohibition, with ancillary orders.
R. v. Gnanasenthan, 2026 ONCJ 656 - Justice Elias
In a criminal prosecution for impaired driving and 80+ operation, the judge dismissed a Charter application and admitted breath readings. Opening the vehicle door on a driveway was a justified safety search; the detention and arrest were lawful, and a brief delay in counsel warnings was justified. Convictions entered on both counts.
R. v. Georgiadis, 2026 ONCJ 598 - Justice Kenkel
In a criminal trial, the Court convicts the Accused of assault with a weapon after finding he twice moved his SUV when he knew the complainant was directly in front or beside it, accepting the complainant’s credible account and rejecting self-defence based on an alleged chokehold.
R. v. D.D., 2026 ONCJ 595 - Justice Perlin cv
In sentencing after a trial, the judge imposed jail for sexual assault of an intimate partner and breach of probation. A conditional sentence was rejected due to denunciation and specific deterrence concerns and the offender’s record. The judge treated harsh remand conditions as significant mitigation, and imposed eight months’ imprisonment (after credit) plus probation and ancillary orders.
R. v. Cabral, 2026 ONCJ 588 - Justice Prutschi
On a s. 490 Criminal Code application to return a seized vehicle, the judge held that the applicant was a bona fide arm’s-length purchaser who conducted due diligence and remained the registered owner in Ministry records. Given s. 490’s narrow scope, the vehicle was ordered returned to the applicant, without prejudice to the other claimant’s civil remedies.
R v. Cutting, 2026 ONCJ 582 - Justice Kenkel
In a prosecution for breaching probation terms arising from a masked home intrusion, the Court held that the intruder’s actions did not support self-defence but found the identification evidence unreliable. Given limited prior recognition and concerns about the photo lineup selection process, identity was not proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Charges dismissed.
Family
M.K. v. T.S., 2026 ONSC 6005 - Justice Daurio
In a parenting trial under the Divorce Act, the judge held the status quo schedule best served the child’s interests. Joint decision-making was ordered with final decision-making authority to the primary caregiver if the parties cannot agree, given intimate partner violence and conflict. A non-removal order and strict travel terms were imposed.
Sealy v. Forde, 2026 ONSC 5984 - Justice Daurio
On a motion for interim spousal support and disclosure under the Family Law Act, the judge finds a prima facie basis for support despite disputed cohabitation and separation dates and alleged delay. Applying the SSAGs, the judge orders $3,825 monthly support, grants disclosure and pension valuation orders, bars a further review motion pending disclosure, and awards $5,000 costs.
Children and Family Services for York Region v. V.C. and T.W., 2026 ONSC 5815 - Justice Finlayson
In a child protection status review, the Court dismisses the Society’s summary judgment motion seeking deemed custody with the paternal grandmother and sharply reduced maternal access. It finds the process procedurally and substantively unfair, including unilateral curtailment of access, failure to address the caregiver’s party status, inadmissible hearsay, and missing collateral evidence. Temporary access directions are ordered.
CFSYR v. B-M. et al., 2026 ONSC 5782 - Justice Law
On a temporary care and custody motion in a child protection case involving Indigenous children, the judge held that the Federal Act’s best-interests framework governs. The children were not returned to their mother due to safety and unmet needs concerns; one child remained with his father and the other was placed jointly with his father and paternal grandmother, under supervision.
CFSYR v. A.T. et al., 2026 ONSC 5737 - Justice Law
On a motion in child protection proceedings, the court held the Minister had a meaningful opportunity to make submissions on an earlier non-removal term and waived it through counsel’s oversight. In any event, a genuine lis existed. The court ordered the parents and child not be removed from Ontario without court approval.
Ghobrial v. Ghobrial, 2026 ONSC 5001 - Justice Daurio
On an interim family law motion for partition and sale, the Court dismisses the request to sell the unencumbered matrimonial home. It finds no unsustainable carrying costs, holds that an arguable exclusive possession claim tied to alleged intimate partner violence requires a trial, and concludes the motion was brought for malicious purposes. Costs awarded to the responding spouse.