November 2026

It's Lawful News

Association and Library news & info



Betty Dykstra

Library Manager

Janet Marchment

Library Technician

Luisa Yepes

Library Assistant

President’s Message

Your voice strengthens our advocacy, and we take your voice to the Federation of Ontario Law Association (FOLA) twice a year. Earlier this month, together with our vice-president, Lambert Kwok, I went to attend the FOLA Fall Plenary to represent the York Region Law Association (YRLA). To interact with the leaders of the legal community across the province, to share the insights and get different perspectives from 46 county and district law associations, with a common mandate of advocating the voice of the practicing lawyers, was a valuable experience once again. 

I encourage our members to visit FOLA’s website, subscribe for its newsletter, and stay updated with the current discussion and the updates in different areas of practice. Additionally, please do visit their Members Rewards section on their website, as many of us may not be aware of the added incentives that we have from being a member of a law association. These are the added incentives to the benefits that YRLA brings for you. We are constantly working towards enhancing our membership and providing more reasons to stay connected with us. Join us, we want to work together with you! 

Warmly, 

Rajni Tekriwal


Upcoming events:

YRLA Family Law Holiday Event at the Paramount Event Space December 14 from 5:30 PM to 8:00 PM  Register

Family Trial Sittings: November 16 - December 4

Library Manager's Message

The frost is on my car; the tires will soon be changed over to the “winters” for those who celebrate. It has been a busy month in the library. The Family Law Sittings are currently underway, bringing new faces and those we have not seen in a while. We have missed you.

I also attended FOLA with the President and Vice-President to hear what is happening from the Association point of view.

Luisa and I travelled to Toronto last month to attend “Learn with LiRN” and Janet tuned in remotely.  We had an update on many things Library, and on new initiatives for the library system.  The best part is it gives us a chance to meet most of our library friends from across Ontario, forge new relationships and brag how our lawyers are the best ever. 

It is also a time to meet with our vendors, strike some deals and find products and books to improve our library for you. The BIG NEWS of this month is that our library now has access to Westlaw Advantage, the AI Legal platform, on all of our workstations in the library.  This product allows the user to use their Deep Research function to search within the Westlaw Platform and the ability to use lawyer functions  such as the Litigation Document Analyzer.  But, that’s not all.  We now have access to LawSource, Practical Law and Legal Memoranda.  We will schedule some training in the new year.  It is new to us and we want the opportunity to acquaint ourselves with this new-to-us product. Please note, this will not replace the valuable Library Staff,  since we are irreplaceable.

I just want to do a quick reminder of our other legal research tools available to you currently in the Library: Lexis+ with Practical Guidance; vLex with Vincent; the numerous texts and of course the wonderful Library Staff (the best research tools).   You have access to the library 24/7 as a member and we are available to assist you M-F from 9-4:30.

The next newsletter will be a mini newsletter in mid-December.  The library will be unstaffed from December 24th – January 4th, 2027. 

Betty

Lawyer Succession Planning

Please let us know if you are retiring or otherwise transferring your files to another lawyer by filling out a brief Transfer of Practice Files form. The Library often receives requests from lawyers and the public trying to locate files in York Region.

Will Search Requests in York Region

Wills and Estates Practitioners, please help locate missing wills by checking the Will Search list regularly. The list is available on the Practice areas > Civil page. Lawyers can also Submit a Will Search Notice on behalf of their clients. 

Send your cute pet pics to Janet at jmarchment@yorklaw.ca so we can feature them in the lounge and our newsletter.

Stress Break

PETS OF THE MONTH:

Momo & Diesel


I was deeply troubled to hear that you did not receive any pet pictures for the October newsletter. This is a profound miscarriage of justice that I will not and can not condone. To that end, I enclose pictures of my cats, which you may freely append to your next letter or up on the wall or whatever you please. 

Momo (orange) and Diesel (white) are  very sweet companions, and I love them; they are also essential staff members of my practice.

Hey, Ask Us!

Need help with a research question?Email us at reference@yorklaw.ca.

We also have eLiRN resources in the library to assist you, including Westlaw (Criminal, Family & Estates Source), LexisNexis (Quicklaw & Practical Guidance) & vLex for searches of Canadian (& some International) cases, legislation, forms and more.

In Your Words

We received a lovely email from a new member:

"Thank you for the warm welcome to the YRLA

Dear Luisa and Betty,

I am writing to express my sincere appreciation for the exceptional support and warm welcome I have received since joining the York Region Law Association a few weeks ago. My experience as a new member has been entirely positive, thanks to your outstanding dedication.

Luisa, thank you for your prompt email responses and for your help in facilitating my participation in the book giveaway. I am thrilled to have won the 2026 Criminal Code. I also greatly appreciate how quickly and efficiently you handled the pickup of my new access card.

Betty, thank you so much for your wonderful hospitality when we met yesterday. The tour of the library and the practical tips you shared were incredibly helpful and made me feel right at home.

The YRLA membership is fortunate to have such a dedicated and professional team supporting us. Thank you both for your exceptional customer service and for everything you do behind the scenes."

And a joke from one of our lawyers:

Did you hear about the librarian who dropped a book on her foot?

She had to get it checked out. 

Notable Cases, Quotes & Articles

We do a lot of reading in the library.  Every once in a while we come across some words of wisdom that are notable...

R. v. A.M., 2026 SCC 33 - On appeal from the Court of Appeal of Ontario
On a Crown appeal from an order for new trials, the Court holds that s. 276 does not categorically apply to sexual services or human trafficking offences. It applies only where an enumerated offence is implicated on the facts. The Court refuses to extend Seaboyer screening and dismisses the appeal, ordering new trials. NOTE: this case was based on s.276 prior to the June 18, 2026 Protecting Victims Act

Bratusa v. Doersam, 2026 ONCA 792 - On appeal from the order of Justice Frederick L. Myers of the Superior Court of Justice, dated August 15, 2025, with reasons reported at 2025 ONSC 4726.

In an appeal from an order staying a dependant’s support application under the SLRA, the Court holds Ontario has jurisdiction. It finds the motion judge erred by rejecting the claimants’ Ontario residence as a presumptive connecting factor; the presumption was not rebutted. The stay and costs order are set aside, and costs awarded to the appellants.

R. v. Silva, 2026 ONCA 779 - On appeal from the convictions entered by Justice Stephen T. Bale of the Superior Court of Justice, on January 26, 2026, and from the sentence imposed on January 26, 2026.

In a sentence appeal, the Court held that the sentencing judge wrongly excluded a conditional sentence based on an erroneous assumption about an outstanding sentence. Resentencing afresh and weighing strong mitigating circumstances and rehabilitation, it set aside the two-year custodial term and imposed a two-years-less-a-day conditional sentence, plus probation.


Jakupovic v. Intact Insurance Company, 2026 ONCA 651 - On appeal from the order of the Divisional Court (Justices Harriet E. Sachs, Nancy L. Backhouse and Stephen T. Bale) dated February 7, 2025, with reasons reported at 2025 ONSC 842, 508 D.L.R. (4th) 545, allowing an appeal from the decision of the Licence Appeal Tribunal dated December 22, 2023, with reasons reported at 2023 CanLII 122890, and a reconsideration decision dated May 21, 2024, with reasons reported at 2024 CanLII 46897.

In an appeal concerning statutory accident benefits, the appellate court holds that s. 32(1) of the SABS requires timely notice of an intention to claim benefits; reporting an accident is not enough and does not trigger an insurer’s duty to inquire. The appeal is allowed, the Divisional Court decision is set aside, and the LAT decisions are restored with costs.


Cycle Toronto v. Ontario (Attorney General), 2026 ONCA 582  - On appeal from the judgment of Justice Paul B. Schabas of the Superior Court of Justice, dated July 30, 2025, with reasons reported at 2025 ONSC 4397, 177 O.R. (3d) 341.

The Court ruled that removing bicycle lanes does not violate Section 7 of the Charter, emphasizing legislative freedom to amend or repeal laws without creating constitutional obligations. The Court found no deprivation of life or security of the person and rejected claims of arbitrariness or gross disproportionality. Appeal allowed.


R. v. Tierney, 2026 ONCJ 604 - Justice Chamberlain

In a sentencing proceeding, the Court held that further jail would not advance sentencing objectives given Gladue factors, rehabilitation, and harsh pre-trial conditions. It granted enhanced pre-trial credit, imposed time served on the break-and-enters, and ordered probation (with a life weapons prohibition and DNA order on the drug count).

Grightmire v. Grightmire-Griesbach, 2026 ONSC 3416 - Justice Hooper

The Court found that RESP funds were impressed with a trust for the beneficiaries' education, rejecting the subscriber's ownership claim. The subscriber was removed for breaching fiduciary duties, including misappropriating funds and imposing unreasonable conditions. A neutral party was appointed to manage the accounts, and repayment was ordered.

Whaling v. Canada, 2026 FC 1266 - Justice Southcott

In a certified class proceeding decided by summary trial, the Court held that retrospective abolition of accelerated parole review breached s. 11(h) of the Charter and was not justified under s. 1. It found Charter damages could serve compensation, vindication, and deterrence, ruled the provision was “clearly unconstitutional,” and applied s. 39(2) Federal Courts Act to avoid a limitations bar.


Recent Newmarket Decisions Found on CanLII - October 2026

Case summaries are CanLII AI-Generated


Civil

Ferrari Estate v. Sukhram, 2026 ONCA 745 - On appeal from the order of Justice Sunil S. Mathai of the Superior Court of Justice, dated October 28, 2025, with reasons reported at 2025 ONSC 6062.

Real property — Sale of lands — Agreements of purchase and sale — Registrar’s dismissal — Appeals

Talpade v. AMJ Campbell Company Toronto East, 2026 ONCA 712

On a motion for security for costs in an appeal from an order striking a claim, the judge ordered security because the appeal appeared frivolous and vexatious, the appellants had unpaid cost orders and insufficient means, and the notice of appeal lacked particulars. Security of $14,900 was ordered, with $5,600 costs.


Orsetto v. 2416022 Ontario Ltd. et al., 2026 ONSC 5689 - Justice Mathai

On a motion to be added as a party after default judgment in an oppression proceeding, the judge finds the moving party’s claimed beneficial interest in a shareholder’s shares may be affected by the ordered sale. However, delay and prejudice to existing parties justify refusing joinder. Limited standing is granted to make submissions on the sale’s manner.


Lincoln Gate Homes Inc. v. DeFrancesco, 2026 ONSC 5606 - Justice De Sa

On a motion to strike a claim and discharge a Mareva injunction, the Court holds there was a strong prima facie case and no material non-disclosure warranting discharge. It grants leave to amend the pleading to remove the corporation as a plaintiff, allowing the action to proceed with the individual plaintiff, and directs further submissions on varying the Mareva amount and access for legal fees.


Criminal

R. v. Cheng, 2026 ONCJ 636 - Justice Perlin

In a sentencing proceeding following guilty pleas, the court denies a conditional discharge. It finds that a police employee’s unauthorised police-database searches and misleading use of a police-style badge involved breach of trust and required denunciation and general deterrence. It imposes a suspended sentence with 12 months’ probation and related conditions.

R. v. Romano, 2026 ONSC 5865 - Justice Di Luca

In criminal sentencing for failing to stop after an accident causing death, the judge finds significant, prolonged recklessness and major victim impact. Despite remorse, no record, and strong rehabilitative prospects, a conditional sentence is rejected as insufficiently denunciatory. The offender is sentenced to 12 months’ custody and a 24‑month driving prohibition, with ancillary orders.

R. v. Gnanasenthan, 2026 ONCJ 656 - Justice Elias

In a criminal prosecution for impaired driving and 80+ operation, the judge dismissed a Charter application and admitted breath readings. Opening the vehicle door on a driveway was a justified safety search; the detention and arrest were lawful, and a brief delay in counsel warnings was justified. Convictions entered on both counts.

R. v. Georgiadis, 2026 ONCJ 598 - Justice Kenkel

In a criminal trial, the Court convicts the Accused of assault with a weapon after finding he twice moved his SUV when he knew the complainant was directly in front or beside it, accepting the complainant’s credible account and rejecting self-defence based on an alleged chokehold.

R. v. D.D., 2026 ONCJ 595 - Justice Perlin cv

In sentencing after a trial, the judge imposed jail for sexual assault of an intimate partner and breach of probation. A conditional sentence was rejected due to denunciation and specific deterrence concerns and the offender’s record. The judge treated harsh remand conditions as significant mitigation, and imposed eight months’ imprisonment (after credit) plus probation and ancillary orders.


 R. v. Cabral, 2026 ONCJ 588 - Justice Prutschi

On a s. 490 Criminal Code application to return a seized vehicle, the judge held that the applicant was a bona fide arm’s-length purchaser who conducted due diligence and remained the registered owner in Ministry records. Given s. 490’s narrow scope, the vehicle was ordered returned to the applicant, without prejudice to the other claimant’s civil remedies.

R v. Cutting, 2026 ONCJ 582 - Justice Kenkel

In a prosecution for breaching probation terms arising from a masked home intrusion, the Court held that the intruder’s actions did not support self-defence but found the identification evidence unreliable. Given limited prior recognition and concerns about the photo lineup selection process, identity was not proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Charges dismissed.

Family

M.K. v. T.S., 2026 ONSC 6005 - Justice Daurio

In a parenting trial under the Divorce Act, the judge held the status quo schedule best served the child’s interests. Joint decision-making was ordered with final decision-making authority to the primary caregiver if the parties cannot agree, given intimate partner violence and conflict. A non-removal order and strict travel terms were imposed.

Sealy v. Forde, 2026 ONSC 5984 - Justice Daurio

On a motion for interim spousal support and disclosure under the Family Law Act, the judge finds a prima facie basis for support despite disputed cohabitation and separation dates and alleged delay. Applying the SSAGs, the judge orders $3,825 monthly support, grants disclosure and pension valuation orders, bars a further review motion pending disclosure, and awards $5,000 costs.

Children and Family Services for York Region v. V.C. and T.W., 2026 ONSC 5815 - Justice Finlayson

In a child protection status review, the Court dismisses the Society’s summary judgment motion seeking deemed custody with the paternal grandmother and sharply reduced maternal access. It finds the process procedurally and substantively unfair, including unilateral curtailment of access, failure to address the caregiver’s party status, inadmissible hearsay, and missing collateral evidence. Temporary access directions are ordered.

CFSYR v. B-M. et al., 2026 ONSC 5782 - Justice Law

On a temporary care and custody motion in a child protection case involving Indigenous children, the judge held that the Federal Act’s best-interests framework governs. The children were not returned to their mother due to safety and unmet needs concerns; one child remained with his father and the other was placed jointly with his father and paternal grandmother, under supervision.

CFSYR v. A.T. et al., 2026 ONSC 5737 - Justice Law

On a motion in child protection proceedings, the court held the Minister had a meaningful opportunity to make submissions on an earlier non-removal term and waived it through counsel’s oversight. In any event, a genuine lis existed. The court ordered the parents and child not be removed from Ontario without court approval.

Ghobrial v. Ghobrial, 2026 ONSC 5001 - Justice Daurio

On an interim family law motion for partition and sale, the Court dismisses the request to sell the unencumbered matrimonial home. It finds no unsustainable carrying costs, holds that an arguable exclusive possession claim tied to alleged intimate partner violence requires a trial, and concludes the motion was brought for malicious purposes. Costs awarded to the responding spouse.


LSO Webcasts Fall 2026

The Library provides reduced fees for LSO Webcasts if we receive registration numbers of 11 participants. We pass those savings on to our YRLA members. They will not be offered as replays, but you can register now and the edited video will be put into your account about 10 days after the live presentation for you to watch later at your convenience. 

Civil Appeals - The Year in Review 2026   Register

Dec 3, 9:00 AM – 12:15 PM   $150   2 h 30 m Substantive   30 m Professionalism

The Eight-Minute Family Law Lawyer   Register

Dec 4, 9:00 AM – 1:00 PM   $150   3 h 20 m Substantive   40 m Professionalism

Impaired Driving 2026   Register

Dec 5, 9 AM - 12:30 PM   $150   3 h 30 m Substantive  0 Professionalism

15th Human Rights Summit   Register

Dec 10, 9:00 AM – 4:00 PM   $220  5 h Substantive   1 h Professionalism


Registration closes at 4pm 7 days before event.
You are not registered until fully paid

Free CPD Hours

Lexis+ Canada Training Sessions for Ontario Lawyers - 1 h Professionalism

•    Lexis+ with over 500 print titles
•    Practical Guidance
•    Legislative Pulse for tracking legislation
•    Brief Analysis - review your brief with the range & depth of Lexis+ coverage

    December 9 at 11AM: https://relx.zoom.us/j/94609326043

    January 14 at 1PM: https://relx.zoom.us/j/95992237907

    February 17 at 12:30PM: https://relx.zoom.us/j/98886674906

    vLex Monthly Webinars

    Vincent AI, Emond Criminal Law Series, Irwin Law Books, Advanced Searching, and mastering the latest enhancements.
    Wed.  Dec 2, 2026  01:30 PM  
     Link to register


    Also...the Library Staff has once again put together the infamous Free CPD Sheet for those last few CPD hours. YRLA Members can check their November 9th afternoon email or contact us at the library for a copy (emails at the top of this newsletter).


    YRLA Library Catalogue

    New Acquisitions

    Books
    Criminal Jury Charge Practice, 2nd Ed
    Debtor-Creditor Law and Procedure, 7th Ed
    Motor Vehicle Accident Tort Claims in Ontario

    Updated Loose Leafs

    Law of Municipal Liability in Canada

    Ontario Planning Law & Practice

    Personal Injury Practice Manual

    Visual Evidence

    Law of Bail in Canada

    Financial and Estate Planning for the Mature Client in Ontario

    LSO Publications

    Eight-Minute Municipal Lawyer 2026
    Eight-Minute Labour Lawyer 2026
    Eight-Minute Employment Lawyer 2026
    Six-Minute Criminal Lawyer 2026
    Family Law Fundamentals 2026
    20th Family Law Summit
    23rd Real Estate Law Summit


    Drinking, Drugs & Driving Law - 

    October 2026
    R v. Maniatis - Inoperable Vehicle
    R v. Serkissoon - Presumptions and Blood Samples Seized Under Warrant

    For Previous Newsletters please click here.

     

    This message was sent to you by {Organization_Name}

    If you no longer wish to receive these emails, you can unsubscribe at any time